Difference between revisions of "Discussions/RulesQuestions"

From Exalted - Unofficial Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Should this be merged into Rulings?)
m (link fix)
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
A place for posting canon rules questions and clarifications. Note there is also the [[Rulings]] page, to record when a consensus is reached.
 
A place for posting canon rules questions and clarifications. Note there is also the [[Rulings]] page, to record when a consensus is reached.
  
*/AttackingFromBehind
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/AttackingFromBehind]]
*/PurchasingSpecialities
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/PurchasingSpecialities]]
*/FireImmaculateDualSwordBenefits
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/FireImmaculateDualSwordBenefits]]
*/GrapplingDamage
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/GrapplingDamage]]
*/ImmaculateMAPowerLevel
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/ImmaculateMAPowerLevel]]
*/StoneOfBloodToFire
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/StoneOfBloodToFire]]
*/AirQuestion
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/AirQuestion]]
*/PoisonPenalties
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/PoisonPenalties]]
*/Swimming
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/Swimming]]
*/TwoSorceryQuestions
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/TwoSorceryQuestions]]
*/CountermagicQuestion
+
*Discussions/[[RulesQuestions/CountermagicQuestion]]
  
Not sure where to ask, but is there an official rule to determine normal swimming speed and where is it? - TonyC
+
Not sure where to ask, but is there an official rule to determine normal swimming speed and where is it? - [[TonyC]]
  
 
The Hearthstone in Castebooke: Eclipse.  They don't have aspects listed.  Has this been errated somewhere, or should I continue to ask the loyal wiki warriors to help me assign them? [[Scrollreader]]
 
The Hearthstone in Castebooke: Eclipse.  They don't have aspects listed.  Has this been errated somewhere, or should I continue to ask the loyal wiki warriors to help me assign them? [[Scrollreader]]
  
 
Does it make sense to integrate this page with the IMO more appropriate [[Rulings]] page? -- [[Wordman]]
 
Does it make sense to integrate this page with the IMO more appropriate [[Rulings]] page? -- [[Wordman]]
 +
 +
:Not a bad idea. There's a slight difference between the two, at least in my opinion, in that in Rulings I specifically try to get an answer, even if it involves making up a house-rule, whereas with Rules Questions I don't mind having the question unanswered. But that is a minor difference and shouldn't be the basis of keepings the two pages separate. - [[TonyC]]

Revision as of 08:06, 5 April 2010

A place for posting canon rules questions and clarifications. Note there is also the Rulings page, to record when a consensus is reached.

Not sure where to ask, but is there an official rule to determine normal swimming speed and where is it? - TonyC

The Hearthstone in Castebooke: Eclipse. They don't have aspects listed. Has this been errated somewhere, or should I continue to ask the loyal wiki warriors to help me assign them? Scrollreader

Does it make sense to integrate this page with the IMO more appropriate Rulings page? -- Wordman

Not a bad idea. There's a slight difference between the two, at least in my opinion, in that in Rulings I specifically try to get an answer, even if it involves making up a house-rule, whereas with Rules Questions I don't mind having the question unanswered. But that is a minor difference and shouldn't be the basis of keepings the two pages separate. - TonyC