Difference between revisions of "FixTheSolarCharmTrees/TripleDistanceAttackTechnique"
m (link fix) |
m |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
== [[Toram]]'s Version == | == [[Toram]]'s Version == | ||
#[[Toram]] | #[[Toram]] | ||
| − | # | + | #NatalieD |
| − | # | + | #MetalFatigue |
#[[Grandmasta]] | #[[Grandmasta]] | ||
| − | |||
===== Comments ===== | ===== Comments ===== | ||
This charm as written seems too weak for a solar charm, particularly when contrasted with <i>Precision of the Striking Raptor</i> | This charm as written seems too weak for a solar charm, particularly when contrasted with <i>Precision of the Striking Raptor</i> | ||
Consider: | Consider: | ||
| − | At short range this charm is useless, while | + | At short range this charm is useless, while PotSR is fully effective. |
| − | At medium range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -2 penalty. | + | At medium range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -2 penalty. PotSR could compensate for 2 motes. |
| − | At long range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -4 penalty; slightly more efficient than | + | At long range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -4 penalty; slightly more efficient than PotSR. |
| Line 34: | Line 33: | ||
This charm's uses are currently limited to: | This charm's uses are currently limited to: | ||
: - Saving one mote when attacking at long range. | : - Saving one mote when attacking at long range. | ||
| − | : - Adding a small additional bonus at medium/long range when | + | : - Adding a small additional bonus at medium/long range when PotSR has already been maxed out on the attack. |
| − | : - Solars who don't also have | + | : - Solars who don't also have PotSR. |
Actually tripling the range of the attack gives this charm a real use, although it still seems fairly weak. - [[Toram]] | Actually tripling the range of the attack gives this charm a real use, although it still seems fairly weak. - [[Toram]] | ||
| − | I'd bet the last slice of pizza that it was intended that way, despite sloppy wording. - | + | I'd bet the last slice of pizza that it was intended that way, despite sloppy wording. - NatalieD |
Revision as of 13:06, 6 February 2005
Contents
Original version
Triple Distance Attack Technique</b>
<b>Cost: 3 motes Duration: Instant Type: Supplemental Min. Thrown: 2 Min. Essence: 2 Prerequisite Charms: None
Triples weapon ranges for purposes of range penalties.
(This effectively eliminates range penalties for a single attack.)
Toram's Version
As the original, except:
Triples weapon ranges (without qualification).
Vote Tally
Original Version
Nobody
Toram's Version
- Toram
- NatalieD
- MetalFatigue
- Grandmasta
Comments
This charm as written seems too weak for a solar charm, particularly when contrasted with Precision of the Striking Raptor
Consider: At short range this charm is useless, while PotSR is fully effective. At medium range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -2 penalty. PotSR could compensate for 2 motes. At long range this charm costs three motes to eliminate a -4 penalty; slightly more efficient than PotSR.
Summary:
This charm's uses are currently limited to:
- - Saving one mote when attacking at long range.
- - Adding a small additional bonus at medium/long range when PotSR has already been maxed out on the attack.
- - Solars who don't also have PotSR.
Actually tripling the range of the attack gives this charm a real use, although it still seems fairly weak. - Toram
I'd bet the last slice of pizza that it was intended that way, despite sloppy wording. - NatalieD
