Toram: Not a disagreement.

2005-03-02T19:06:39Z

Not a disagreement.

New page

||Page||Type|[Description||Reporter||
||64||UNCLEAR|[In the <i>Manse Deterioration</i> section, the more the manse is used, the higher the difficulty of the roll to make the manse deteriorate, and thus, the less deterioration there will be. This isn't consistent with the text of that same section.||[[Toram]]||
||104||UNCLEAR|[In the spell <i>Dance of the Smoke Cobras</i>, it says "Whenever a cobra is destroyed before the spell expires, it regrows on its next action...". But the spell never specifies its duration.||[[Toram]]||
== Comments ==
p64: I'd suggest reversing the difficulty modifier, so light use is difficulty 5, and heavy use is difficulty 1. --[[Toram]]
:I'll have to take a look when I have the book in front of me, but this seems to simply be a rule that you disagree with... if so, then by your own guidelines it ought not to be in this section. -[[szilard]]

::Not so; the book says that the more a Manse is used, the greater the risk of deterioration, but the mechanic described has the opposite effect. I would have labelled it a CONTRADICTION, but it's within the same paragraph. --[[Toram]]

p104: I'd suggest a duration of the caster's Essence in turns. --[[Toram]]

Szilard: unclear?

2005-03-02T17:58:15Z

unclear?

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 ||Page||Type|[Description||Reporter||
-||64||UNCLEAR|[In the <i>Manse Deterioration</i> section, the more the manse is used, the higher the difficulty of the roll to make the manse deteriorate, and thus, the less deterioration there will be.  This isn't consistent with the text of that same section.||[[Toram]]||
+||64||UNCLEAR|[In the <i>Manse Deterioration</i> section, the more the manse is used, the higher the difficulty of the roll to make the manse deteriorate, and thus, the less deterioration there will be.  This seems backward.||[[Toram]]||
 ||104||UNCLEAR|[In the spell <i>Dance of the Smoke Cobras</i>, it says "Whenever a cobra is destroyed before the spell expires, it regrows on its next action...".  But the spell never specifies its duration.||[[Toram]]||
 == Comments ==
 p64: I'd suggest reversing the difficulty modifier, so light use is difficulty 5, and heavy use is difficulty 1.  --[[Toram]]
 :I'll have to take a look when I have the book in front of me, but this seems to simply be a rule that you disagree with... if so, then by your own guidelines it ought not to be in this section. -[[szilard]]
 p104: I'd suggest a duration of the caster's Essence in turns.  --[[Toram]]

FixTheSloppyEditing/SavantAndSorcerer - Revision history

Toram: Not a disagreement.

Szilard: unclear?